4 Barrel BBQ

Best BBQ Restaurant in Arvada, Colorado!

  • Home
  • About
  • Menu
  • BBQ Joint
  • Gallery
  • Recipes
  • Cooking Guides
  • Buyer’s Guide
    • Barbeque
    • BBQ Accessories
    • Outdoor Cooking
    • Kitchen Appliances

The 10 Best Drum & Barrel BBQ Smoker for 2023 Reviews

February 27, 2023 by Jackson 2 Comments

If you want to take your cooking skills to the next level or need the right BBQ smoker to break into the smoking and grilling world, you can’t go wrong with the Drum & Barrel BBQ Smoker.

It’s easy to get deceived by its funny look. This product will soon find its way to your heart and become your cooking companion. They are fuss-free to set up and use with gentle heat to cook your meat slowly for more tender and juiciest results.

If this sounds like something that interests you, then you should check out our list of the top 10 best drum & barrel BBQ smokers. Also, you don’t want to miss out on our detailed buying guide and FAQs to ensure you are making an informed decision.

Table of Contents

  • Top 10 Best Drum and Barrel BBQ Smoker Reviews for 2023
    • 18-1/2 in. Classic Pit Barrel Cooker Package
    • EasyGoProducts Big Bad Barrel Drum Charcoal Barbeque 5 in 1-Smoker
    • Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS443CB-D Heavy-Duty Compact Barrel Charcoal Grill
    • Weber 18-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker
    • Oklahoma Joe’s 19202089 Barrel Drum Smoker
    • Oklahoma Joe’s 19202099 Bronco Pro Drum Smoker
    • Barrel House Cooker Smoker
    • Royal Gourmet CC2036F Charcoal Barrel Grill with Offset Smoker
    • Burch Barrel BBQ Smoker Grill & Fire Pit Combo V2
    • Pit Barrel Cooker Junior PBJ Package
  • Things to Consider When Shopping for the Best Drum & Barrel BBQ Smoker
    • Construction
    • Size
    • Beginners Guide To Drum Smokers
  • FAQs:
    • Why should I consider a drum and barrel BBQ smoker?
    • What are the main problems with a drum smoker?
    • Is this the BEST drum on the market…? | Out the Smoke Gateway Drum Review
  • Conclusion

Top 10 Best Drum and Barrel BBQ Smoker Reviews for 2023

18-1/2 in. Classic Pit Barrel Cooker Package

18-1/2 in. Classic Pit Barrel Cooker Package
View at Amazon

 

This brand’s name, Pit Barrel Cooker, already gives it away. This manufacturer produces a series of reliable BBQ smokers to be every cook’s best friend. The Classic model offers a more traditional feel like the original drums with just the basics for a simple, delightful smoking experience.

This model offers two cooking options – meat hooks or a standard grill grate. The manufacturer recommends cooking your meat by hanging using the 8 meat mooks over the grill grates. It seems to make much more sense to us as well. Hanging your meat helps you maximize its cooking space since it’s relatively small.

Talking about cooking capacity, the Classic Pit Barrel Cooker Package is only a 30-gallon cooker, unlike the traditional options measuring up to 50-gallon. This portable BBQ smoker makes up for its small cooking space with unbeatable cooking speed. This machine cooks twice as fast as most products on this list.

As said earlier, this model comes only with basic features, which means you shouldn’t be expecting wheels, a thermometer, or a hinged lid.

Pros:

  • Comes with 8 meat hooks and hanging rods
  • Grill grate features porcelain-enameled 18-gauge steel
  • Impressive heat retention and distribution
  • Easy to use – set-and-forget operation style

Cons:

  • Does not comes with wheels for easy transportation and maneuvering

EasyGoProducts Big Bad Barrel Drum Charcoal Barbeque 5 in 1-Smoker

EasyGoProducts Big Bad Barrel Drum Charcoal Barbeque 5 in 1-Smoker, Grill, Pizza Oven, Table and Fire Pit, Tool Set, Black
View at Amazon

 

When it comes to versatility, you can bank on EasyGoProducts Big Bad Barrel Drum Charcoal Barbeque 5 in 1-Smoker. This unit can serve as a table, fire pit, and cooker. This 45-pound smoker is perfect for medium-sized gardens and patios. This model features a rugged porcelain-enameled steel construction that guarantees it serves your purpose for many years to come.

This drum reaches up to 225 degrees F and is equipped with an airflow system for even heat distribution. Coupled with the built-in thermometer on the lid, this smoker maintains the set temperature. Further, it comes with six hooks and two cooking grids, which means you cook two different dishes simultaneously – provided the cooking temperature is right.

What’s more? This EasyGoProducts Big Bad Barrel Drum Charcoal Barbeque 5 in 1-Smoker rocks heat-proof handles to make transportation a breeze. Even better, users can easily adjust the barrel and rack’s heat to regulate the cooking temperature.

Pros:

  • Equipped with an accurate thermometer
  • Multifunction design
  • Comes with handy cooking utensils
  • Good value for the money
  • Durable construction

Cons:

  • Assembly can be a bit time-consuming

Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS443CB-D Heavy-Duty Compact Barrel Charcoal Grill

Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS443CB-D Heavy-Duty Compact Barrel Charcoal Grill
View at Amazon

 

If you need a barrel with average-sized cooking space, the Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS443CB-D is the way to go. This product measures about 443 square inches of cooking space, which should be enough to cook a meal for up to 4 hungry people.

That’s not all: it features a heavy-gauge steel body construction that assures us that this model will last many years. For the sake of safety, Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS443CB-D comes with a cool-touch spring lid handle that offers a safer way to retrieve your food.

Further, this model has a side access door to easily dispose of ashes and add fuel with ease. Additionally, we love its porcelain-enameled cook grate for its impressive heat retention. Plus, it’s equipped with an analog temperature gauge for precise cooking. Also, it comes with a ‘SmokeZone’ and ‘GrillZone’ indicator to take out the guesswork.

Pros:

  • Easy to use and clean
  • Superior heat retention
  • Oversize wheels for easy transportation
  • Comes with an analog temp gauge

Cons:

  • Thin frame that requires you to babysit the grill

Weber 18-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker

Weber 18-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker, Charcoal Smoker
View at Amazon

 

This Smokey Mountain Cooker comes from Weber, one of the top brands in this space. This capsule-shaped BBQ smoker is perfect for feeding a medium-sized crowd. This unit is one on the lighter side and has enough cooking space to fit a whole turkey.

This 18-inch cooker supports slow cooking and can attain up to 190 degrees F. The included instruction manual made assembling this cooker a breeze. Also, the lid features an in-built thermometer to allow you to keep track of the cooking temperature.

On top of that, it comes with rugged and long-lasting enameled-steel cooking grates. It comes with a metal rung to provide the much-needed support to the smoker to prevent sinking into the ground. The Weber 18-inch Smokey Mountain Cooker features vents, which open and close easily, to control the cooking temperatures.

Although it’s an 18-inch model, it features a compact design, making it easy to transport and use in average-sized backyards. Aside from its ease of use, users can transform this barrel smoker into a grill. With its low temperature and slow cooking, this product delivers fork-tender grilled steaks and ribs.

Pros:

  • Easy to use and assemble
  • Vent for better temp control
  • Available in different size options
  • Versatile design – barbecuing and grilling
  • Excellent heat retention

Cons:

  • High maintenance to prevent rusting

Oklahoma Joe’s 19202089 Barrel Drum Smoker

Oklahoma Joe’s 19202089 Barrel Drum Smoker, Black
View at Amazon

 

Next is a barrel drum smoker from one of the leading brands, Oklahoma Joe. They have a variety of styles and sizes. The Oklahoma Joe’s 19202089 has a little visual appeal for a barrel smoker. This model is engineered with durability in mind that’s hard to argue.

It features heavy-gauge steel construction, porcelain-coated components, and large wheels. On top of that, you get an ash pan, heat diffuser, drain cup, and charcoal basket. Another thing worth talking about is its hinged lid offering a secure seal to trap heat, moisture, and flavor. Also, it means you don’t have to deal with an overwhelming amount of smoke outdoors and more inside the drum for a sweet, smoky flavor.

Coming with an oversized charcoal basket to hold a large amount of wood and charcoal for a long smoking session. This beast features an efficient airflow system to deliver precise temp management and control. Furthermore, it’s effortless to clean.

Pros:

  • Turns into a charcoal grill easily
  • Includes a side shelf for additional space
  • Oversize wheels for easy transportation
  • Oversized charcoal basket for long smoking hours

Cons:

  • On the heavier side

Oklahoma Joe’s 19202099 Bronco Pro Drum Smoker

Oklahoma Joe’s 19202099 Bronco Pro Drum Smoker, Black
View at Amazon

 

It’s hard to find a smoker that outperforms the Oklahoma Joe’s 19202099 Bronco Pro Drum Smoker. This unit comes with a 17-pound fuel capacity to allow you to cook for a long time. Also, you get a large 21.5″ cooking space, which is plenty enough to cook a large meal for a hungry crowd.

Like the Oklahoma Joe’s 19202089 Barrel Drum Smoker, this unit brings competitive performance with its unique airflow control system offering precise control and consistent smoking temperature. Furthermore, it comes with 9 meat hooks, 3 meat hangers, cooking grates, and a heat diffuser for a custom smoking experience.

These porcelain-coated components, a large ash pan, and a drain cap for no-fuss cleanup. Needless to say, the Oklahoma Joe’s 19202099 Bronco Pro Drum Smoker features a heavy-gauge steel construction to make sure this beast lasts a long time.

Pros:

  • heavy-gauge steel construction
  • Superior airflow control system
  • 17-pound fuel capacity
  • Generous cooking surface of 21.5 inches
  • Hassle-free to clean
  • Available in black and orange

Cons:

  • Adding wood is a bit challenging

Barrel House Cooker Smoker

Barrel House Cooker Smoker BHC 18C
View at Amazon

 

The Barrel House Cooker Smoker comes complete with 8 meat hooks, a built-in thermometer, manual and instruction booklet, Barrel House Cooker, H-frame, and one accessory wand. This model has a decent cooking temperature range from 275 – 310 degrees F for a fast Low ‘n’ Slow cooking experience.

That’s not all: it features a detachable base that makes cleaning and lightening the smoker a breeze. Also, it allows turning this incredible smoker into a hibachi grill and more portable.

Speaking about portability, the Barrel House Cooker Smoker is lightweight and has a small footprint, making it perfect for your patio. Its vertical hanging method helps you maximize your limited cooking surface area. It weighs about 45 pounds, which means you should have no trouble strapping this smoker into your truck.

More so, it can hold up to 8 pounds of charcoal for more than 6 hours of smoking time. To impart your food with a sweet smokey flavor, you can add wood chips and chunks to the charcoal briquette for extra flavor. Equally important, the Barrel House Cooker Smoker is engineered with a 20 gauge metal barrel with its exterior and interior porcelain enameled for superior durability.

Pros:

  • Built to last
  • Small footprint with lightweight design
  • More than 6 hours of smoking time
  • Easy to clean and transport

Cons:

  • It seems it has been discontinued

Royal Gourmet CC2036F Charcoal Barrel Grill with Offset Smoker

Royal Gourmet CC2036F Charcoal Barrel Grill with Offset Smoker, 1188 Square Inches for Large Event Gathering, Outdoor Camping, Picnics, Patio and Backyard Cooking, Black
View at Amazon

 

Looking for a massive cooking space to cook for a hungry crowd? The Royal Gourmet CC2036F offers 654 square inches cooking grates, 267 square inches offset smoker, and 267 square inches warming rack – is all that enough?

These components are crafted with heavy gauge porcelain-enameled steel wire. The offset smoker is attached to the barrel grill to promote better smoke and heat circulation. This add-on provides extra smoking or grilling space to create sumptuous side dishes.

On top of that, this model comes with an adjustable charcoal pan offering three height levels for optimal heat control. It has a 7.7-pound fuel capacity to smoke for a long period without refueling between sessions. Also, it has a side charcoal door to allow you to load the coal for an uninterrupted smoking experience.

Pros:

  • 3-level height adjustable charcoal pan
  • Tremendous cooking surface area
  • No-fuss cleanup
  • Side charcoal door

Cons:

  • The design could be better

Burch Barrel BBQ Smoker Grill & Fire Pit Combo V2

Burch Barrel BBQ Smoker Grill & Fire Pit Combo V2 – Adjustable Hanging Vertical Smoker with Tripod System – Charcoal or Wood Pellet Outdoor Portable Barbeque
View at Amazon

 

Want something different? You can settle for the  Burch Barrel BBQ Smoker Grill. This model is a suspended BBQ firepit that easily becomes the centerpiece for any outdoor gathering. This versatile device offers different cooking functions – roast, flame sear, and smoke.

The Burch Barrel BBQ Smoker Grill & Fire Pit Combo V2 is a great choice for professional and novice BBQ pitmasters. This model is equipped with 9 different heat settings and works well with your preferred flavored wood pellets, chips, chunk, or charcoal.

More so, it comes with adjustable legs that stay stable and offer a level cooking surface regardless of terrain surface. The tripod is effortless to disassemble for an on-the-go smoking experience.

Pros:

  • 304 Stainless steel construction
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Portable design for an on-the-go experience
  • Adjustable design for convenient cooking

Cons:

  • Customer service could be better

Pit Barrel Cooker Junior PBJ Package

14 in. Pit Barrel Cooker Junior PBJ Package
View at Amazon

 

This list won’t be complete without this best drum & barrel BBQ smoker from Pit Barrel. This model has a small footprint but doesn’t be deceived. This portable cooker punches above its weight.

Speaking of its small capacity, this unit is still perfect for cooking six chicken halves, six racks of ribs, full packer brisket, a 17 pounds turkey, and many more. It has a similar cooking performance to the 8.5 Classic Pit Barrel Cooker but is more portable to fit any car.

This model is another set-it-and-forget-it model from the Pit Barrel Cooker built to sear, grill, and smoke. What else? We love this unit for its low fuel consumption and affordable price point.

Pros:

  • Suitable for tailgating, camping, etc.
  • Versatile cooking function
  • Lightweight and portable design
  • Simple temperature control
  • Low price point

Cons:

  • Poor quality control

Things to Consider When Shopping for the Best Drum & Barrel BBQ Smoker

Construction

If you want a drum smoker to serve you for many years, you need to settle for a highly durable unit. These rugged devices are usually made of steel and treated with a weather-resistant finish for more durability. Also, it guarantees the drum smoker can withstand the harsh elements.

Some model exterior and interior are coated, usually porcelain enamel. Aside from durability reasons, this coating improves the drum’s heat retention and makes cleanup a breeze.

Size

The size is another factor you want to bear in mind when shopping for the best drum and barrel BBQ smoker. Most products are available in either 30-gallon or 55 gallons. However, some smaller models come with a 16-gallon drum.

For portability and on-the-go smoking experience, you want to stick to models with smaller capacity. These portable drum smokers are suitable for camping and tailgating.  On the other hand, hosting big parties in your backyard requires larger models. These models should come with a large fuel basket to hold more coals for a long smoking session without refueling between sessions.

Beginners Guide To Drum Smokers

FAQs:

Why should I consider a drum and barrel BBQ smoker?

They are versatile, fuel-efficient, portable, and inexpensive. They come in handy to cook a wide variety of foods.

What are the main problems with a drum smoker?

In our opinion, these cookers have limited cooking space. However, there are some models with a unique structure to offer more cooking surface area. Keep in mind; it doesn’t look like the traditional models.

Is this the BEST drum on the market…? | Out the Smoke Gateway Drum Review

Conclusion

There you go -the top 10 best drum & barrel BBQ smokers and how to make the right choice. We are confident that any of the models on this list will bring incredible cooking performance and versatility to improve your skills for mouthwatering results.

Filed Under: Barbeque, Buyer's Guide

About Jackson

I'm a self-proclaimed barbecue expert and author of 4Barrel BBQ! I'll be honest with you, I started this website because my infinite love for barbecue. Along my journey, I actually really fell in love with writing about barbecue. I hope you found value from whatever article you read. It's the work, the mission that I'm doing

Trackbacks

  1. Best Smoker Box for Gas Grill for 2021 Reviews- 4Barrel BBQ says:
    October 23, 2021 at 4:15 am

    […] box is like a container designed to hold wood chips to convert your gas grill into a full-fledged barbecue smoker. They are usually made of cast iron or stainless steel. This gadget is perforated at the top to […]

    Reply
  2. Barrel House Cooker vs Pit Barrel Cooker- Making the Right Choice says:
    October 24, 2021 at 2:08 pm

    […] Top 10 Best Drum & Barrel BBQ Smoker for 2021 Reviews […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4barrelbbq.com

Guides & Recipes

Texas-Style Oven Briske

Which Is the Best Texas-Style Oven Brisket Recipe

Jack Daniels BBQ Sauces Recipe

Jack Daniels BBQ Sauces Recipe [2023 Updated]

Smoked Pork Belly

Smoked Pork Belly Recipes [2023 Updated]

How to Smoke A Brisket on A Pellet Grill

Pellet Grill Brisket Recipe and How to Smoke A Brisket on A Pellet Grill

Myron Mixon Smoker Cookbook

The Best Myron Mixon Smoker Cookbook [2023 Reviewed]

Pork Belly Burnt Ends Recipe

Pork Belly Burnt Ends Recipe With Myron Mixon’s Pitmaster BBQ

4Barrel BBQ © 2021 All Rights Reserved: About - Privacy Policy- Affiliate Disclaimer
4barrelbbq.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.